An S-corp election is one of the most common recommendations made to business owners and one of the least revisited. It's usually set up in a profitable year and then runs on autopilot. Two questions deserve a regular look, and they're more connected than they seem.
Question one: is the election still earning its keep?
An S-corp isn't a different kind of business. It's a way of being taxed. A single-member LLC or an existing C-corp, for example, can elect S-corp treatment.
Here's where the savings come from. As a sole proprietor, all of your profit is treated as pay for your work, so all of it is subject to self-employment tax, a 15.3% rate for Social Security and Medicare. With an S-corp, the profit splits in two. Part of it is a paycheck for the work you do, and that part is taxed like any wage. The rest is the business's profit passing through to you as an owner, and it isn't subject to those payroll taxes. You still pay regular income tax on all of it, so the taxes you avoid are the payroll taxes on the part you take as distributions (Social Security and Medicare).
Simplified example
A business earns $120,000 and the owner pays themselves a $60,000 salary. Payroll taxes apply to $60,000 instead of $120,000, which can mean roughly $7,800 less tax before the costs below.
The sole proprietor figure is 15.3% of 92.35% of the $120,000 profit (about $16,955). The S-corp figure is 15.3% of the $60,000 salary ($9,180). The estimate ignores income tax effects and the Social Security wage limit.
The catch is that the IRS requires the salary to be reasonable for the work you do, so the more profit there is above a defensible salary, the larger the potential savings.
Against that, there are costs: payroll processing, a separate business tax return every year, added compliance time, and state and local entity-level taxes and fees. New York and New York City, for example, treat S-corps differently than the federal government does. In a strong year the savings usually outweigh the costs. When profit falls or becomes uneven, they may not. The answer comes from comparing real numbers, not from a rule of thumb.
Question two: is your salary still reasonable?
If you work in the business, the IRS expects you to be paid a reasonable salary for your services before you take distributions. Pay yourself too little and the IRS can reclassify distributions as wages, which brings back payroll taxes. Unpaid payroll taxes can also carry penalties and interest. There's no flat percentage that works. What's reasonable depends on factors such as your training and experience, your duties, the time you devote to the business, and what comparable businesses pay for similar work.
Salary isn't something you set once. It's a number you should be able to explain, and the explanation changes when the business does.
Setting it too high has a cost too, because you give up savings you didn't have to. Salary also interacts with other parts of your return, including retirement plan contributions and the qualified business income deduction, so changing it moves more than payroll.
Why I look at them together
The salary you can defend determines how much the election saves, so the two questions can't be answered separately. Each year I model the business's projected profit, test a defensible salary range, and compare the result with and without the election. If the numbers still work, we document the salary and move on. If they've shifted, we find out early enough to act.
A simple yearly S-corp checkup
- Has profit changed meaningfully since the salary was last set?
- Is the salary documented, and does it still match your role and the profit?
- Is payroll running on schedule, with filings current?
- Are distributions being tracked against your basis?
- Do the state and local entity-level costs still fit the picture?
This article is general information, not tax advice for your specific situation. Tax rules, thresholds, and due dates change, so confirm what applies to you before acting.